THE MARKETER OF THE DAY PODCAST

MacKenzie Scott Published Fiction Again. What Should Returning Writers Revive?

On August 8, 2026, MacKenzie Scott started publishing her first published novel in 13 years, one installment at a time on Substack. Last Days in Two Nations (A History in Eighteen Minds) continued through an August 31 epilogue, turning a long gap between published novels into a concrete decision. She chose a format and put another work of fiction in front of readers.

Most returning writers are dealing with a much smaller and messier version of that decision. There may be an old manuscript on a hard drive, poems from 20 years ago, half-finished essays, a newsletter that quietly died, or a folder full of work that once mattered enough to save. The interesting question is what, if anything, is still worth bringing back.

That is where my conversation with poet WL Gertz became useful to me. WL Gertz described himself as being “back on the scene after a 50 year hiatus,” but his story is different from MacKenzie Scott’s 13-year gap between published novels. He said he wrote little for a long period, then returned with poetry collections that deliberately combine work from the early 1970s with poetry written in the last two years.

What caught my attention was that WL Gertz did not look at the older work and decide it belonged to some completely different person. He could still recognize himself in it. His style, as he put it, “really hasn’t changed in 50 years.” The bizarre and surrealistic qualities were still there, even though decades had passed and the person doing the reading was obviously older.

That creates a more interesting problem than simply asking whether old writing is good or bad. Some of it may be weak. Some may be dated. Some may contain one strange line, image, argument, or rhythm that still feels more alive than the polished material you could write today.

Returning to creative work starts with figuring out what still deserves another look.

A Return to Publishing Is Only One Decision

MacKenzie Scott’s August release is useful partly because the publishing choice was so specific. She chose Substack as the delivery channel and released the novel in installments during August. For a returning writer, that is a much more practical thing to study than the surrounding celebrity attention.

Access to publication has changed. That does not make all the other parts easy. Getting readers is a separate problem. So are receiving favorable reviews, building an audience that returns, and earning enough from writing to support yourself.

MacKenzie Scott already had enormous name recognition before the first installment appeared. An ordinary writer should be careful about treating the attention around her release as evidence of what Substack, self-publishing, or any other platform will produce for someone without that built-in recognition.

A platform can give you somewhere to publish. It cannot manufacture interest in the work simply because you clicked Publish.

The later criticism makes that distinction even sharper. On September 27, Business Insider published a review by Eve Sneider that was sharply critical of the novel’s storytelling and presentation. That is one critic’s judgment, not a final verdict on the book, but it is a reminder that putting work into circulation does not control the response.

Direct access to readers also does not remove the need for editing. Fewer logistical barriers between writer and reader do not make every draft ready, every strange choice effective, or every old piece worth reviving.

That matters if you have been away from creative work for years. You can spend months wondering whether you are still a writer, whether the market has changed too much, whether your old material matters, or whether you missed your chance. None of those questions has to be settled before you make a smaller decision about one piece of work.

WL Gertz talked about the new environment in practical terms. He remembers when finding obscure poetry, music, literary criticism, or older cultural material took much more effort. In the interview, he talked about the web making that material readily available and specifically mentioned Substack as one of the newer places where writers can publish and readers can discover their work.

He did not say that he personally publishes on Substack. His broader observation was about access. Writers have more ways to put work in circulation than they did when he was young and, as he said, had no idea how to market himself.

That difference is easy to underestimate if you stopped publishing years ago.

A writer coming back after a long absence may no longer be facing the same gatekeeping problem that existed when the work was first written. The harder editorial question can become whether the material deserves publication in its current form.

WL Gertz’s own return helps make that distinction useful. After a long hiatus from the scene, he selected older work, put it alongside newer work, and continued writing.

For an ordinary writer, the sensible scale is one piece and one bounded decision. MacKenzie Scott’s audience is not the model. The useful part of her example is that a return to publication can be an identifiable act rather than a declaration about the rest of your creative life.

Old Work Can Still Sound Like You Without Still Being Good

WL Gertz’s return is useful because he did not treat the older material as something that had to be disguised as new. He described Broken Dreams and Land of Forgotten Fish as collections that clearly separate poems from the early 1970s from work written much more recently.

He also included material connected to dreams magazine, the publication he was involved with in New York that mixed poems, manifestos, literary criticism, and writing about rock and roll.

The older work was not being passed off as if it had all been written yesterday. The newer work did not need to imitate the past.

What surprised WL Gertz was the continuity. Talking about his poetry, he said his style “really hasn’t changed in 50 years.” He described that style as bizarre and surrealistic, and he said he has never liked poetry that feels obvious or predictable.

For a returning writer, that creates a better question than simply asking whether something is old.

You may read something you wrote 15 or 30 years ago and immediately see problems. The sentences are too long. The argument wanders. The references have aged badly. A joke no longer lands. A paragraph explains something three times because you did not yet trust the reader to get it.

None of that makes the entire piece useless.

There may also be something in it that you would have trouble reproducing now. Maybe it is an image you would not think of today. Maybe it is a strange turn of phrase. Maybe it is a point of view you had before years of professional writing taught you to smooth every rough edge.

WL Gertz’s experience is interesting because he recognized the same creative fingerprint across decades. That does not make his early poems automatically good. He is quite blunt about the fact that there is bad poetry in the world, including plenty of it online.

What survived was recognizable character.

That distinction gets lost easily when you return to your own work. Writers can become protective of old material because it feels personal. They can also attack it because it is embarrassing to encounter an earlier version of themselves on the page. Either reaction can make editing harder.

Something coming from an earlier version of you does not make it precious or disposable.

The way WL Gertz assembled his collections provides another useful possibility. Older and newer work can sit next to each other without pretending there was no gap. Time itself can become part of the context.

A returning writer can use that idea without copying his format. An old essay can retain its original date. A poem can be presented with a short note explaining when it was written. An abandoned chapter can supply one scene or argument for something new. A rough piece can be revised instead of preserved intact.

The useful distinction is between identity and execution.

You may recognize your voice in an old piece while admitting that half the sentences need work. You may still like the central idea while deciding the structure has to go. You may find one paragraph that feels unusually alive sitting inside ten pages you never want anyone to see.

At that point, nostalgia has done all the work it can do. Editing has to take over.

The harder editorial problem is deciding whether the strange thing is worth preserving or whether you are defending a weak passage simply because you wrote it years ago.

Keep the Strange Line. Fix the Weak One.

An old piece can contain one sentence you still like and three paragraphs you no longer trust. That is a better starting point than declaring the whole thing brilliant or embarrassing.

WL Gertz gives us a reason to take unusual language seriously. He said he dislikes obvious poetry, described his own work as bizarre and surrealistic, and recognized those qualities in writing separated by decades.

That supports preserving something unusual when it is doing real work. Confusion by itself is not proof of depth.

A strange image can make a reader stop because it opens a new association. A confusing passage can make a reader stop because the sentence has no direction. Those may both feel unconventional on the page, but they are different editorial problems.

Suppose you are rereading an old essay and find one image you would never think to write today. It is specific, odd, and memorable. The paragraph around it circles the same point three times and never quite arrives anywhere.

You do not have to preserve the paragraph to save the image. Keep what has life in it and rebuild the argument around it.

Or suppose an old poem depends on a reference that made immediate sense when you wrote it but now requires context. Changing the poem is only one option. You might preserve the original language and add a short note explaining when it was written or what the reference meant at the time.

That is different from quietly rewriting the past until the old work sounds exactly like something you would produce today.

The same reasoning applies to voice. A younger version of you may have been less polished but more willing to say something awkward, funny, blunt, or unfashionable. Years of professional writing can improve structure while also sanding away habits that gave the work personality.

The goal is not to imitate your younger self. It is to notice whether the old piece contains something distinctive that no longer appears naturally in your newer work.

WL Gertz’s resistance to obvious poetry is useful here as a prompt rather than a rule. Look at the piece and ask what still feels specific enough that another writer probably would not have written it the same way. Then ask whether the surrounding material earns its place around that stronger material.

A distinctive sentence does not rescue a weak argument. A personal memory does not excuse ten pages of repetition. An unusual metaphor does not make a piece finished. You can preserve individuality while cutting aggressively.

One practical way to inspect an older piece is to read it once without editing and mark only what still catches your attention.

Read it again looking for the opposite. Find the passages that are vague, repetitive, unfinished, or dated in a way that creates confusion. On those first two passes, resist the urge to decide the fate of the entire piece.

Then decide what kind of object you actually have.

Maybe the original is mostly sound and needs revision. Maybe its original date and context are important enough that you should preserve them. Maybe one section belongs inside something new. Maybe the only thing worth carrying forward is a single image or argument. Nothing surviving inspection is also a legitimate result.

Opening an old file does not create an obligation to rescue it.

Once you know what is actually there, the decision shrinks to a manageable size. You can decide what happens to this one piece without having to decide whether you are returning as a writer forever.

Publish One Thing Before Planning the Next Ten

Once an older piece has survived that inspection, the next move should fit the material you actually have.

A piece that is mostly sound may deserve a real revision and a publication date. If its age is part of what makes it interesting, its original context may belong beside it. If the whole thing no longer works but one line still has energy, that line can become the beginning of something new.

There is no reason to turn this into a tour of publishing platforms. The important choice is the form that lets you complete this particular piece and put it somewhere another person can encounter it.

For one writer, that might be a revised essay. Another might record a short reading. Someone else may take one usable passage from an old draft and write forward rather than spending weeks repairing a piece they no longer believe in.

WL Gertz’s experience matters here because publication changed what he wanted to do next. He said publishing encouraged him to keep writing, then described the contrast with the long period before his return: “I didn’t write much, I would say for a long time, but now I really want to write again.”

That is his experience. It is not a promise about what publication will do to your motivation.

Your piece may attract very little attention. Finishing it may generate three new ideas, or none. You may discover that you loved revisiting the material but have no interest in returning to a regular writing schedule.

All of those outcomes give you more information than leaving the same file untouched for another five years.

A public deadline can help if you tend to keep revising indefinitely. That is simply an option. Pick a date close enough that you have to make decisions and far enough away that you can do the work properly.

Then keep the assignment from growing.

One revived essay does not require a 12-month content calendar. One rediscovered poem does not require reopening 200 files. A line worth saving does not obligate you to rescue the notebook around it.

Give the piece a boundary and complete the decision you made about it. That is enough to find out whether finishing this one leaves you wanting to write another.

The next decision can stay small.

WL Gertz’s return was not limited to looking backward. He brought earlier work and newer poetry into circulation, recognized parts of himself across that distance, and found that publishing increased his desire to write again.

Give that one piece an honest outcome, whether that means finishing it for readers, using part of it to make something new, or deciding that it has already done all the work it needed to do.

Decisions, Courage, and Action — book cover

You may have one old piece worth finishing, even if you’re still unsure what comes after it. WL Gertz brought older work back into circulation and found himself wanting to write again, and he’s also one of my co-authors in Decisions, Courage, and Action. Pick up the book on Amazon to read his contribution.

About WL Gertz

<a href=WL Gertz” class=”wp-image-263741″/>

WL Gertz is a poet whose books Broken Dreams and Land of Forgotten Fish combine work from the early 1970s with more recent poetry. His writing draws on travel, New York’s literary and music culture, and the surrealistic style he says has remained recognizable across decades. Earlier in his career, he was involved with dreams magazine, which featured poetry, manifestos, literary criticism, and rock and roll writing. Connect with WL Gertz on LinkedIn.

Media and interview inquiries: To request an interview about poetry and returning to writing, use his contact form.

Resources


Essential features — always available
Forms, spam protection, and podcast playback.

Optional Google Analytics runs only after you accept Analytics. Advertising tags stay off. Change your Analytics choice on the Privacy page.

How these choices work. You can change them anytime from the footer.