Robert Plank 0:00 What makes a business valuable, and why can't a profitable company still be difficult to sell? We have the man, the myth, the legend, the master, Mr. David C. Barnett, fourth-time guest on the podcast here, with an amazing new book that's called "Business and Asset Values: How Owners, Buyers, sellers, lenders, and advisors should think about small business and equipment value. And he's drawn on years of experience in small business transactions, financing, valuation, machinery, and equipment appraisal. So David C. Barnett shows us why value is never just a number; it's the result of cash flow, risk, market demand, asset quality, transferability, financing conditions, and the expectations of real buyers and sellers. So whether you're building a company, evaluating an investment, preparing for succession, financing a transaction, advising a client, settling a dispute, or trying to understand the assets already on your balance sheet. This might be the most important podcast you ever listen to or watch, and we need to know all this information right now about this book, which is not just about buying or selling a company. It's this guide to understanding what you own, what makes it valuable, what threatens that value, and what must be true for someone else to recognize and pay for it? So important, Mr. David C. Barnett. Good to see you again. David Barnett 1:28 Hey, Robert. Thanks for the flattering introduction. That's awesome. Robert Plank 1:32 That's why we're here, right? I'll be your hype man all day long. And so, how have you been? It's it's been I think maybe five. Used to come on the show every couple years, but it's been maybe five years since the last visit. So, what's new? What's exciting? David Barnett 1:45 Well, what's new is the new book, and you know my kids are graduating from high school, so it's a whole new chapter of life for me. But I sat down earlier this year and I started to work on a book. And you know, in addition to helping people buy and sell businesses, we have an appraisal practice for machinery and equipment here regionally, and I sat down in January and I wanted to create sort of a how-to guide around machinery and equipment values. And as I started to write this, what was supposed to be you know like an ebook or something I could share with people, it just started to to expand, and I just started to naturally get into new areas. And then I realized, hey, I need to back it up here and start at a different point. And so the book just project just started to expand on its own until finally it ended up being 250 pages, and it starts in the beginning with the story of a hot dog to explain the value of money and how it isn't really money that holds value-it's what we perceive as value. If you want, I can tell you the hot dog story. Do you want to hear it? Robert Plank 2:48 Let's hear it. David Barnett 2:49 All right. So it's, it's first thing in the morning. You get up, you have breakfast, and you go to work, and it's close by. So you walk, and you walk through a park. And when you walk through the park, there's a hot dog vendor getting set up, and there's a sign there that says "hot dog and a soda, $5, and you have a $5 bill in your pocket, but you're not interested because you just had breakfast. It's 9o'clock in the morning, and so at that moment in time, you would rather own the $5 bill. You get to work, you spend your morning at your desk. Around 1130, your stomach starts to grumble, and then you remember the hot dog guy. So then you go leave the office, you go back to the park, and you decide to buy the hot dog and the soda for $5, and you trade. In that moment, the hot dog and the soda became more valuable to you than the $5 bill. And the whole point of the story is is that during this entire story, the hot dog, the soda, or the $5 bill-none of those things changed at all. The only thing that changed was your attitude towards them, because at one point the sort of tipping point was achieved. You wanted one more than the other, and so I use that story to illustrate the value of money, because the value of money is just one thing in this hierarchy of wants and desires that we always have, where everything that's available to us is moving up and down as far as how much we want it, and then from there I move into you know naturally the next thing and the next thing and the next thing, and I take people all the way through concepts like substitution, you know the time value of money, how $1 today is worth more than $1 tomorrow. I talk about you know how the value of things changes over time with respect to substitution. You know, if you buy something today for $10,000 and tomorrow a new better version becomes available for 7000, nobody's going to pay you 10,000 for the thing you just bought for 10,000. And so I illustrate these concepts that appraisers use when they're looking at machinery, equipment, or or anything really, and I apply them using the storytelling technique so that the layperson who is not an expert in finance or accounting is going to be able to understand how these different values are derived. One of the one of the key statements I like to make. Is that you know people like to think of value as a number, right? We can say the hot dog and the and the soda are worth $5, but they weren't worth $5 in the morning. If you haven't eaten in two days, you might argue that they're worth a lot more than $5. You might pay anything to get them, right? But I say that value is not a number; it's a conclusion connected to a decision, and ultimately that's why people go out and hire someone to do an appraisal or an evaluation of a business or a piece of machinery because they're tasked with some sort of decision that they need to make, and they're feeling that they need some kind of supported evidence to help them make that decision, which is what the appraisal is, right? And so, you know, over my career, I've worked with many different people. I've worked with business owners who wanted an idea of how much they might be able to sell a business for. I've worked with business buyers who are trying to figure out what to offer for a business, and the same business working for those two different clients, I could come up with with a different result because the seller wants to know, based upon what other people have done in other transactions, is going to be the likely selling price for their business. And there's a way to discover that and substantiate it and show that seller like this is likely what it's going to sell for. But when I'm working with the buyer, one of the questions I'm going to have for the buyer is how much money do you have? How much of a down payment do you have? David Barnett 6:22 Because now we can figure out how much money you're going to have to borrow, and so we could very well start at the conclusion that the seller had, but because of the difference in resources that the buyer has, the the ultimate sort of plan that's put in front of that buyer could be a very different sort of arrangement. So it could include, for example, a different price, but it might be the same price under different kinds of terms that are actually going to work for that that buyer. One of the the things that people often talk about in the world of business is goodwill, and I address goodwill in the book, and I talk about how appraisers determine what goodwill is. But goodwill can't be figured out unless you know the value of the cash flow, which is you know what the business's value is, and you know what the value of the tangible assets inside the business are, because goodwill is determined indirectly that way. But furthermore, a lot of business owners who might want to sell a business are confused about what exactly goes in that transaction. So you could have two people believing a business is worth the same amount of money, but the sellers believing I'm going to keep my cash, I'm going to keep the accounts receivable, I'm going to keep my cell phone number because I've had it for 40 years. On the other side of the table, the buyer is looking at it, saying this business, the way it's been built, has all these customers who expect to pay in 60 days. So the operating capital required to support the accounts receivable are just as important as the forklift that loads the delivery truck. So if I'm going to buy this business, it's got to come with that operating capital as well. It's part of what makes the business work. And so I explore all of these things in the book and talk about the different points of view and how misunderstandings around some of these fundamental things can really demonstrate that people are far apart on on on what the value is. Well, one of the ultimate sort of issues is the opinion about transferability. When we talk about a publicly traded stock like shares of Coca Cola, for example, if you're going to buy shares of Coca-Cola. Part of that investment is being made in the leaders and the people who have been there forever and have a plan, and you know know what they're going to do next year, and they deliver part of the value of what you're investing in. But when you buy a small business, the leadership, the planning, the experience, all of that usually departs with the seller leaving, and the buyer steps in and has to fill that role, and so part of the reason why there can be a different opinion about what this thing is worth is the question of just how much of that business continuity is going to be transferred over to the buyer, the transferability of the business. So these are all things explored in the book, and and you know, one of the reviewers who got an early copy said something really great. They said this book isn't going to teach you how to do an appraisal of a business. What it's going to do is help you better navigate bad appraisal conversations or bad value conversations. And I've seen this happen a lot, where people like a lawyer, for example, who you know doesn't work in the field of business valuation at all, but will often end up at a table with a client discussing some contracts or something to do with a business transaction, and we'll start to be asked questions about what they think or what they feel about what's being proposed or what's being you know offered in something in some way, and then they'll start to talk about it. And I've seen deals go off the rails before because somebody who really doesn't have any idea what is going on in the business expresses an opinion that's not connected. Anything that influences one of the principles of the deal, and the thing falls apart, and it's a shame when it happens because oftentimes you know people are stuck in a bad situation. Well, I'll tell you one quick story. David Barnett 10:11 It's a manufacturing business that has to do with forest products, and so they're they're they had this huge inventory of stuff in their business, and if you added up the value of the equipment, the machinery, and the inventory, it added up to a certain number. But if you paid that number for the business and you had to borrow three quarters of that value, the cash flow of the business would never support that debt. So what had happened was this business is what I describe as a zombie business. It's it's a walking dead capital kind of business because too much had been invested in it and it didn't warrant the cash flow that came out of it, and so what needed to happen for this business was vast reductions in inventory. They had to figure out their systems better. They either had to get more sales and get that inventory turning faster, or they had to identify what just wasn't selling. They had to either mark it down, or blow it out, or just write it off and get it off the books, so that they could get this business into a condition that was actually, you know, it made sense to make an investment to acquire this business given the cash flow that it produced. So the buyer and seller worked at this over the course of three years, and the seller, you know, finally had that deal with the buyer, and the buyer was happy with the deal because it finally made sense. And when the seller got to his lawyer, the lawyer looked at the deal and said, "Why would you give such a great deal to this person? You know, your stuff is worth so much. I would never do this, etc. etc. and basically the comments of the lawyer derailed the whole deal. And then the buyer walked, and this seller, who's now a gentleman in his late 70s, is still stuck in that business. Like he had the opportunity to leave, and because of someone's misinformed opinion, like he lost his opportunity. That's that's the kind of bad valuation conversation that I'm talking about, and anybody who works with a business owner, like any kind of coach, consultant, you know, etc. or anyone who owns a business or aspires to build a business they might sell one day, for example, is going to get tremendous value out of this book. Robert Plank 12:20 Very nice. You packed a lot into that that one answer, and I mean, doesn't that happen a lot sometimes? It's like if we're not properly like educated, prepared, or maybe even like have have a thick enough skin, emotional intelligence, enough in in our circle. One little comment, one little opinion can mess up this one deal, transaction, situation, and then it leads to a whole other chain of events, and we want to avoid that. And so it's like it-you've you've turned it into something that's really fun, haven't you? Because it's like numbers on their own are boring, but when you throw in a story of like these different types, it can make it interesting, right? There's the there's kind of like the the education story where like you tell the the hot dog story and it kind of forces us to slow things down and add some repetition, but it doesn't feel like repetition because you're like telling a tale and then eventually we understand this thing that maybe we ourselves don't have to implement, but it pays to be educated. And then there's like a little bit of the like the the selling and buying story, where you say, "Well, here's the business is worth this number, but hey, like we'll break it down, and there's the this amount, this issue with the financing, you apply it to that, and so it just kind of adds character dimension to something that otherwise might maybe put us to sleep a little bit, but because you kind of you infuse it with the the excitement and the the people factor, it kind of it makes things a lot more interesting and avoids us having these uneducated mistakes, right? If you let emotion play too much of a part in it, or there's not enough logic, then it's like the the math problem doesn't work out. You might as well be just having a random number, and maybe that's why these people that are looking to buy, sell, maybe. That's why they're so frustrated because they need a book exactly like this. David Barnett 14:05 Well, you know, there is one Amazon review now that actually describes it as a page turner. So I was I was pretty shocked when I saw that. I thought, oh, that's good because my my goal in writing it was to be engaging, you know. And I and I and I tried to you know have a little bit of fun with some of the examples. You know, one of the examples I talk about a pizzeria, right? Because everybody's been in a pizzeria. We're familiar with what it looks like. There's a big oven. You know, there's there's people with the giant paddles. You know, the people throwing the dough in the air and all that kind of stuff. And you know, I talk about the pizzeria and you know what the oven is worth, and we talk about the pizzeria business, and then we talk about the pizzeria guy getting a divorce, and so that I can talk about what the wife's divorce attorney thinks the pizzeria is worth, and we compare that with you know what the business broker says that it's worth, and then I talk about how the the pizzeria guy then gets a new girlfriend, and she wants to. To a new city, and as his circumstances change, it changes the framing of the deal, and so I get to introduce sort of these different motivating factors, so that you actually see somebody move through these different dimensions that that I see people go through all the time. You know, somebody who is healthy and happy in their business, and it makes good money, and they intend to stay there for the next 25 years, and it's that business is worth a tremendous amount to them. The minute you say, "I want to now sell this business to a stranger who is going to step into my shoes, be concerned about their ability to take over, and they're going to have to shoulder a big debt in order to buy it, and that means that their cash flow that they're going to enjoy is going to be greatly constrained, probably for 10 years if it's an SBA loan. It's very easy to start understanding how that business isn't worth nearly as much to that new owner than it would be to the person who's already in it, and and you know I I run into this all the time with with actual business owners, you know, when I show them this is what your business will likely sell for, and a lot of them will scoff and say, "Geez, if I just stayed here for a few more years, I'd have the same money and I'd still own it. It doesn't make sense for me to sell. I'm like, it never makes sense. It never makes sense to sell a good cash flowing business. They they just don't sell for enough money because of the risks attached to them. But when somebody becomes motivated, when they realize they can't do it anymore, when they get bad news from a doctor or something like that, then all of a sudden their attitude and their opinion takes a dramatic change, and then they start to look at it and say, "Well, I know I can't stay here now for the next 20 years. So, what are now the best available options once I've accepted that, and that, and that's and that's how people move through this progression of different values, and you know we we don't really hear those stories in the popular media. What we hear about are these fantastical Silicon Valley stories where somebody produces something that grows exponentially, and they sell out for hundreds of millions of dollars. Or we we hear about the guy who built the business in the popular industry, and the you know big city investment bankers come and help him sell it for a huge you know multiple of cash flow, and that guy sells out and buys a big yacht. And those stories are the ones that spread because they're the attractive, sexy stories, but they don't tell the story of 99% of small businesses, and that's part of the issue that we run into is that people get into these transactions, sellers approach their retirement, and they have this idea of what it's going to look like, shaped by these stories they've heard, and they're usually not prepared for the reality of what the marketplace is going to be able to deliver for them. Robert Plank 17:46 Ooh, that's a good insight. And yeah, I do have guests like that sometimes. My nickname for that is podcast catnip. When you have one of these guys that's had four exits, seven exits, and you think like, okay, well they they sell for the multiple, and it's like three years, four years of the business, but they do that like every two years, and they're just like accelerating time. It's such a cool story, and it's it is exciting, right? But it's like the the the guys that you watch playing football or baseball on TV; those are like the upper tier. Those are the ones that like have really gone for the survivorship bias, and you're saying the the reality is maybe it makes sense to have some possibilities, and so that way we can stay in the business, and it's a smoother run business if we choose to stay. But if if the worst happens, or if life gets in the way, or we get bored, we get old, we get sick, whatever, then we have these these possible exit paths that makes the best out of a perhaps bad situation. David Barnett 18:46 Yeah, the, the, the wealth generating impact of of small business is in owning a profitable small business. It's not in the exit transaction. If if you own a profitable small business that is producing good cash flow for you, you keep that thing. That is a golden goose. It's only when you reach a certain point where there's an issue, either. And listen, it could be internal. It could just simply be that you've lost your interest, you've lost your passion. That's an important time to get out too, because if you don't have the passion to keep fueling that business, to keep energizing the staff, and and you know showing people that you're delivering value, then your attitude change is going to have an impact on that business. So that's also a reason to get out. But as long as you can keep it going and things are going well, it makes more sense just to run them over the long term for sure. Robert Plank 19:37 Feels like real estate, doesn't it? These people that they put all this effort into flipping, and they only like they might spend you know all this material money, but they only get like a one-time payday versus these guys that they have all these properties and they're just kind of cash flowing a few $100 a month, but they have they keep putting money back in the business, and it's like they they let it ride, and so it's like uh yeah, it's it's good to to be aware of some of the. Factors where the emotions, especially, can change the numbers, and it's just it's fun and fascinating to hear about how you have multiple, not not even always two, but like just multiple different people in a deal, and they all have a different number, and it's a matter of just like figuring out those negotiations. And so, like you said, you wrote this book that kind of took on a life of its own, right? It was supposed to be just a simple guide, and it turned into something that all of us can learn from, whether we're at that point of buying or selling, or just are looking towards and planning for the future. So that way, there'll be more reliability and less unexpectedness. If that's the most awkward phrase I've ever said my whole life, and so in this conversation we're having here about all these things that go into the valuation and fair market value and accounting, et cetera, do you think there might be a missing question in this conversation that I should be asking you? I just don't know what to ask you. David Barnett 20:58 Well, you brought up real estate, and one of the chapters of the book, the chapter immediately after I talk about how business values are determined, I ask the question: Does the value make sense? And so this is when I bring in other asset classes, and so I talk about you know government bonds and publicly traded stocks, and I then I also compare three different types of real estate, and then I plot them all on a chart, on a graph, showing people you know how they relate to each other, and it becomes very, very clear how the sort of transferability on one axis and rate of return or yield on the other axis makes these things line right up, and you can actually see how those prices for small businesses that I mentioned earlier seem kind of low actually make perfect sense when they stand in a line beside all those other different kinds of investments. You know, when like I said, when you buy the shares of Coca-Cola, you don't have to worry about the transferability of the value because you're investing in all the leaders and people that know what they're doing over there, and they're going to keep operating that business for you, which is very different from that pizzeria where you have to step in and and make sure that you don't you know drop the ball on a busy Friday night getting all those pies out to delivery. Robert Plank 22:16 Right, a lot of factors we don't consider, right? The, the risk factor and the owner sweat equity and and so much more. And so, if someone out there in podcast land says this is some cool stuff, I know that I need to be educated properly by Mr. David C. Barnett. What's the next step? Where should we go? David Barnett 22:35 Well, you know, I've been making videos on YouTube now for over 11 years. There's 900 of them, and I talk about buying, selling, financing, and managing small and medium-sized businesses. So, if you look up David Barnett's Small Business on any podcast, app, or YouTube, you're going to find me right away. And if you want to check out the book, it's on Amazon, Business and Asset Values. And I would love for you to buy a copy and then please leave an honest written review so that other readers can see what you thought of the book. It's starting to get a lot of reviews, and they've all been positive, which has just been very exciting for me. You know, I've written books before. I've spoken about a couple of my earlier books with you on the show before in those past visits, and so I put in the reps, which is why I think this book is particularly good because I've, I've had some time to to work at this. Robert Plank 23:24 Very nice. You finally got it right, and I get that feeling sometimes too. That like sometimes you have the I mean false start kind of isn't isn't the right term, but you sometimes you're like whoa like everything I've done has led to this as far as the the clarity, the simplicity, the helping people you just hit on all the right notes and you finally made it. You've arrived, as they say, with this book that you recently published called "Business and Asset Values: How Owners, Buyers, Sellers, Lenders, and Advisors Should Think About Small Business and Equipment Value. And you know the way I've recently thought about it, David, is it's like the the book is the movie, the the podcast and the videos is the TV show, right? Like the movie, it's like the best stuff. It's the one time thing, but then to get the ongoing weekly episodes, that's why that YouTube channel that you have in the podcast is so important. And you did such a cool thing there where you're training the search engines for that search phrase. So don't just go to a link, you people, on podcast land. Search on Google David Barnett Small Business, and that way you can go to YouTube or podcast, your favorite learning tool of choice, and you can teach those AI, SEO, Google algorithm gods that David Barnett Small Business leads you to this YouTube channel with 955 videos with 85,000 subscribers, where you can stay up to date about some of these true stories. Should you buy business with a partner, SBA loans, and so much more. That way, you can visit the minutia, but then to get that foundation. Knowledge that book is business and asset values. How owners, buyers, sellers, lenders, and advisors should think about small business and equipment value. As David said, it's such a cool and fun read. You'll be entertained, engaged, and amazed. And once you read it and you like it, make sure to go to that comment section on Amazon and leave an honest review. That way, you can be also helping others get the answers that they need as well. So, business and asset values is the book. But before I let you go, Mr. David C. Barnett, it's time for the scary part of the podcast, where I try to stump you. I try to put you on the spot by asking you about a fun or interesting quote or lesson that has served you. So, what comes to mind as far as a fun or interesting quote or lesson? David Barnett 25:46 Oh, a fun or interesting quote or lesson. You know, there's one in here right at the end of that first chapter from an economist by the name of Ludwig von Mises, and he was what from what they called the Austrian School of Economics, and it you know this story kind of the the quote kind of highlights what it is. So so Ludwig von Mises says the ultimate source of determination of prices is the value judgments of the consumers, and he wrote that at a time when people really were confused about where prices came from, and he wrote that in response to Karl Marx, who had written that he believed that prices had to do with the cost of making something-that you you you took the inputs and you had to put some kind of quote-unquote fair you know markup to represent your labors, and that's what he had written about in the the Communist Manifesto. And Ludwig von Mises says, no, you know, I mean, you can make some really expensive stuff nobody wants. It's not going to be worth anything, or you can make something that people really do want and want it very badly, and it's going to be worth a lot. And it's really the judgment of the individual that is going to determine what the price is, and ultimately that is going to send a signal to the makers of things to know what to make, right? You know what people want, what they're willing to pay for is what should be made, and and today, you know, extending his philosophy, we've ended up with you know iPhones and all the other cool stuff that we have. Robert Plank 27:19 It's such a cool concept to think about. Why is the price of gas this? Why is the price of Bitcoin that? Why is a stake $10 over here and $100 down the street? And if we can get a grasp on this idea, then boy, we can go far. We can go places in our future business and entrepreneurial success. So let's check it out. The book is Business and Asset Values by David C. Barnett, and what a nice return visit you made on the podcast, Mr. David. One for the history books. Thanks for coming back. David Barnett 27:50 Thanks, Robert, for having me. It's been great. Have a great day.